Commentary November 17 2026

Gordon Robinson | Cricket crossroads

3 min read

Loading article...

  • West Indies players celebrate. West Indies players celebrate. Photo - CWI Media
  • West Indies players celebrate. West Indies players celebrate. Photo - CWI Media
  • Gordon Robinson Gordon Robinson. Photo - Contributed

The growing popularity of “Bazball” among Test Cricket coaches is, for me, the most reliable sign that Test Cricket, as we knew it, is terminally ill.

What’s “Bazball”? It’s an attitude to batting introduced to the English Test team in 2022 by head coach Brendon McCullum (nicknamed “Baz”) that calls for a high-risk, aggressive batting attitude; dismissal of fear of failure; and an insistence that batsmen (I will NOT call them “batters”) score at record-breaking pace hitting sixes and fours as often as possible.

It’s the T20ization of Test Cricket. And it has turned Test Cricket on its head.

Since 2022 England’s Bazball team has won 8 of 15 Test series and lost only 3. England swept New Zealand 3-0; won 3–0 away to Pakistan; Defeated South Africa 2–1; and secured high-profile 2-2 home series draws against Australia and India.

In the “Bazball” era England has played 49 Test matches, scoring at an all-time record pace of 4.45 runs per over while conceding 3.58 runs per over.

“Bazball” seems to have caught on. Although nobody will publicly admit this, other countries are quietly trying to emulate this new, aggressive approach to Test cricket. Pakistan briefly experimented with increasing their scoring rate and held pre-series training camps focusing on more aggressive batting. No Pakistani Coach has used the moniker “Bazball”.

Traditional powerhouses like India and Australia already possessed or independently leaned into proactive or attacking players (Travis Head is the best current example but I can remember Adam Gilchrist, Matthew Hayden and, before them, the great Doug Walters) so had no need to admit they’re doing anything different. West Indies were known as “Calypso Cricketers”.

Keen observers have surmised that England’s high run-rates forced other Test nations to reconsider flat or slow-scoring approaches, though no other board or team officially accepted “Bazball” as its style. But, ask yourself, why was John Campbell recalled to the West Indies Test side and Kraigg Brathwaite sidelined? Why is Brandon King his opening partner instead of the more old-fashioned opener Tagenarine Chanderpaul?

In the recent two-Test series in Bangladesh, West Indies’ team run rates were 2.96; 4.83; 3.33; and 4.27 respectively. Openers’ strike rates were 75; 70.43; 50; 72.61 (King); 69.23; 89.09 (Campbell; ruled out of second Test with a fever). Campbell’s replacement as opener, Joshua DaSilva scored at 70.58 and 51.42.

Chanderpaul batted Number 3 in the first Test and scored at 30.43 and 6.66. He also sat out the second Test with a fever. His replacement Kevin Wickham scored at 42.06 and 72.89

Need I say anything more? Sammy won’t tell you but it’s “Bazball”!

One of the key consequences of “Bazball” is that the days of specialists are over (no pun intended). Iconic Inshan Ali wouldn’t be invited to a Test squad today. Alf Valentine and Sonny Ramadhin would be carrying water bottles (water carts are also obsolete). And don’t get me started on the greatest of all time, Lancelot Gibbs. Jomel Warrican, who I’ve been begging selectors for years to give a permanent place in the side, batting at Number 9, scored 0; did not bat; 27 not out; did not bat in Bangladesh and was a match winner with the ball.

But the poster boy for what “Bazball” has done to Test cricket is young English specialist right-arm off-spinner Shoaib Bashir. At 23, Bashir reminds me very much of a young Lance Gibbs who could bowl all day with men clustered around the bat and produce wicket-taking balls with regularity. Bashir has a similar high release point and imparts vicious spin. At 23 his potential is limitless. But he isn’t even in England’s squad for its upcoming three-Test tour of South Africa. Instead uncapped 28-year-old Nottinghamshire spinner Liam Patterson-White, who can best be described as limited, gets the call.

The UK Guardian’s cricket analyst Jonathan Liew wrote (November 12) about Bashir: “A passenger in the Ashes, sidelined for most of the home Test series…. his omission has formalised what we basically already knew for a while: that he is essentially a locum, a fringe presence, a luxury player, a squad-packer. For most of the last year he was always getting dropped without ever really being dropped. Now he has been dropped for real, and something more abstract appears to have been followed him out of the door: an idea, an archetype, perhaps even an entire kind of cricketer, and perhaps for good.”

Apart from the obvious that the aptly named Patterson-Whites of this world always have the edge over Bashirs in English national team selection the reality is Bashir doesn’t bat. Not really. His County Cricket batting average is 7.56 while Patterson-White’s is 24.09 with two first-class centuries.

That’s Bazball for you. In Bazball, bowlers who can bat are preferred to bowlers who can bowl. Cricket is at a crossroads. As a legend of USA’s version of Bazball, Yogi Berra, once advised “When you come to a fork in the road, take it!”

Peace and Love.

Gordon Robinson is an attorney at law. Send feedback to columns@gleanerjm.com